Best Dog Chews for Teething Puppies in 2026: Safe Relief for Sore Gums

Last updated: December 28, 2025

Puppies begin their teething journey around 3 weeks of age, with full sets of deciduous (baby) teeth emerging by 8 weeks. At approximately 3-4 months, permanent teeth begin pushing through, creating pressure and discomfort in the gums that can last through 8 months or longer. During this critical phase, the right teething chew isn't just a luxury—it's essential for soothing sore gums, satisfying natural chewing instincts, and redirecting destructive behavior away from your furniture and belongings.

This comprehensive guide evaluates the top dog chews specifically designed for teething puppies, focusing on safety, durability, and proven effectiveness for puppies aged 8 weeks to 8 months.

Table of Contents

• Quick Comparison Table
• How We Evaluated Puppy Teething Chews
• What to Look For
• Natural vs Synthetic Puppy Chews: What's the Difference?
• Product Reviews
  • KONG Puppy Classic - Best Overall
  • Benebone Puppy Wishbone - Best Durable
  • Himalayan Yak Chews - Best Long-Lasting
  • Nylabone Just for Puppies - Best Budget
  • Olive Wood Natural Chew - Best Natural
• Detailed Comparison Table
• Quick Reference Guide
• Care Tips / How to Use
• Common Mistakes When Buying Puppy Chews
• FAQ
• Final Verdict

Quick Comparison Table

How We Evaluated Puppy Teething Chews

We assessed teething chews for puppies based on comprehensive criteria to ensure reliable recommendations for puppies aged 8 weeks to 8 months:

• Safety - No choking hazards, splinter-free, appropriate size for puppy mouth
• Durability - Longevity during intense chewing sessions without rapid degradation
• Teething Effectiveness - Ability to soothe sore gums and provide appropriate resistance
• Engagement Value - Sustains interest through flavor, texture, or interactive features
• Digestibility - Safe if small pieces are consumed accidentally
• Supervision Requirements - Level of monitoring needed during chewing sessions

We evaluated products based on veterinary recommendations and extensive user feedback from puppy owners.

Natural vs Synthetic Puppy Chews: What's the Difference?

Natural puppy chews (like yak cheese or olive wood) offer authentic textures and flavors that closely mimic natural chewing experiences, often with digestive benefits but requiring more careful supervision. Synthetic puppy chews (like rubber or nylon) provide consistent durability and safety features with less mess, though they may not satisfy instinctive preferences for natural materials as effectively.

What to Look For

Before selecting teething chews for your puppy, consider these essential features:

• Age Appropriateness - Products specifically formulated for puppies, not adult dogs
• Size Guidelines - Appropriate for your puppy's current size and expected adult size
• Safety Features - No small parts, rounded edges, and supervision recommendations
• Flavor Appeal - Natural scents or flavors that attract puppies
• Texture Variety - Different surfaces to massage gums and clean teeth
• Value Proposition - Durability relative to cost and expected lifespan

Detailed Product Reviews

Important: Product headings must use HTML <h3> tags with explicit IDs (e.g., id="1-product-name-best-overall") instead of markdown ### headings. This ensures Table of Contents links work correctly, as rehype-slug may modify IDs for headings that start with numbers. The ID format should match the TOC link format exactly (lowercase, hyphens, no special characters).

1. KONG Puppy Classic - Best Overall

The KONG Puppy Classic is a soft rubber toy made from natural rubber, specifically formulated to be gentler on puppy gums than adult versions. Its unpredictable bounce engages play drive while its hollow center can be stuffed with treats, peanut butter, or even frozen kibble for extended engagement.

Pros:

• Made from KONG's softer natural rubber formulation designed for puppy teeth
• Hollow design allows stuffing with treats, peanut butter, or wet food
• Available in Small, Medium, and Large sizes for puppies of different breeds
• Bounces erratically to stimulate play and mental engagement
• Machine washable for easy cleaning
• Vet-endorsed for teething relief

Pros:

• Made from KONG's softer natural rubber formulation designed for puppy teeth
• Hollow design allows stuffing with treats, peanut butter, or wet food
• Available in Small, Medium, and Large sizes for puppies of different breeds
• Bounces erratically to stimulate play and mental engagement
• Machine washable for easy cleaning
• Vet-endorsed for teething relief

Cons:

• Requires supervision during play sessions
• May need frequent cleaning if stuffed with food
• Not suitable for very aggressive chewers

👉 View on Amazon

---

2. Benebone Puppy Wishbone - Best Durable

Made in the USA with a slightly softer nylon material than adult versions, the Benebone Puppy Wishbone combines durability with gum-friendly comfort. Each purchase includes two toys—a dental chew with ridges and a wishbone shape designed specifically for small paws to grip.

Pros:

• Real bacon flavor (100% real bacon, not artificial)
• Softer nylon material formulation for teething puppies
• Two-piece pack: dental chew with plaque-cleaning ridges + curved wishbone
• Paw-friendly grip design for easy holding during chew sessions
• Made in the USA
• Available in Tiny (under 15 lbs), Small (under 30 lbs), and Medium (under 60 lbs) sizes

Cons:

• Not edible (monitor for small pieces that could be swallowed)
• Requires rotation with other toys to prevent boredom
• May be too hard for very young puppies

👉 View on Amazon

---

3. Himalayan Yak Chews - Best Long-Lasting

Himalayan yak chews are 100% natural, artisanal chews made from Himalayan yak and cow milk. These dense, durable chews can last for weeks or even months, making them exceptional value despite their higher price point. The hardened cheese-like texture provides intense sensory engagement without the risk of splinters.

Pros:

• 100% natural—only yak milk and cow milk, salt, and lime juice
• Sustainably sourced from the Himalayas
• Extremely long-lasting (weeks to months for puppies)
• Microwave-safe: leftover pieces can be microwaved into a puffed "cheese puff" snack
• Splinter-free and highly digestible
• Naturally scented to appeal to puppies' olfactory drives

Cons:

• Higher price point than synthetic alternatives
• Requires supervision to prevent overconsumption
• May cause digestive upset if too much is consumed

👉 View on Amazon

---

4. Nylabone Just for Puppies - Best Budget

Nylabone's puppy-specific teething ring is a flexible, softer nylon chew designed specifically for young dogs with developing teeth. The ring shape allows puppies to grip and control the toy while the flexible nylon prevents the hard chewing damage that adult Nylabone products can cause.

Pros:

• Flexible nylon formula—softer than adult Nylabone products
• Ring design allows natural grip and control during chewing
• Available in Flavor Medley and Chicken flavor options
• Designed for puppies up to 15 pounds
• Ridged surfaces help clean teeth and freshen breath
• Affordable price point

Cons:

• May wear down quickly with very aggressive chewers
• Not suitable for puppies with allergies to certain flavors
• Requires regular replacement

👉 View on Amazon

---

5. Olive Wood Natural Chew - Best Natural

Olive wood chews are 100% natural, sustainably sourced wood chews that provide the authentic chewing experience of a stick without splinter risk. Each chew is carefully sanded and polished to eliminate sharp edges, making them safe for teething puppies while satisfying their instinct to gnaw on wood.

Pros:

• 100% natural olive wood—no artificial materials or coatings
• Sustainably harvested from olive groves
• Sanded and polished smooth—splinter-free surface
• Available in three sizes for different puppy growth stages
• Long-lasting (weeks to months depending on chewer intensity)
• Naturally antimicrobial properties of olive wood

Cons:

• May cause digestive issues if large pieces are consumed
• Not suitable for puppies with wood allergies
• Requires careful supervision

👉 View on Amazon

---

Detailed Comparison Table

Quick Reference Guide

Care Tips / How to Use

1. Supervise Always - Never leave puppies unattended with any chew toy
2. Size Appropriately - Choose toys that are too large to swallow whole
3. Rotate Toys - Provide variety to prevent boredom and overuse injuries
4. Clean Regularly - Wash toys before and after use to prevent bacterial growth
5. Inspect Frequently - Check for damage and discard worn or damaged toys
6. Introduce Gradually - Allow puppies to explore new toys under supervision

Common Mistakes When Buying Puppy Chews

Avoid these frequent errors when selecting teething chews for puppies:

1. Using Adult Toys - Adult chews are too hard for developing puppy teeth
2. Ignoring Size - Toys that are too small pose choking hazards
3. Skipping Supervision - All chewing sessions require adult oversight
4. Buying Single Toys - Puppies need variety to stay engaged
5. Neglecting Flavor - Strong, appealing flavors keep puppies interested

FAQ

Q: When does puppy teething typically begin and end?

A: Puppy teething begins around 3-4 weeks when deciduous (baby) teeth start emerging, with all 28 baby teeth usually in place by 8 weeks. Adult teeth begin pushing through around 3-4 months, causing the most discomfort. Teething can continue through 6-8 months, though discomfort usually peaks between 4-6 months.

Q: How often should I replace puppy chews?

A: Replace chews immediately if they show significant wear, cracking, or damage. Even undamaged toys should be rotated regularly (every few days) to maintain interest. Natural chews like yak cheese may last weeks, while softer rubber toys may need replacement every 1-2 weeks.

Q: Can puppies chew on adult dog toys?

A: No, adult toys are too hard and can damage developing puppy teeth or cause jaw injuries. Always choose toys specifically designed for puppies, which are formulated with softer materials appropriate for baby teeth.

Q: What size chew toy is appropriate for my puppy?

A: Choose toys that are too large to swallow whole but small enough for your puppy to carry comfortably. For puppies under 15 pounds, look for "puppy" or "small" sizes. As puppies grow, you can transition to slightly larger toys, but always supervise use.

Q: Are natural chews safer than synthetic ones?

A: Both can be safe when chosen appropriately, but natural chews require more supervision as they can splinter or cause digestive issues if large pieces are consumed. Synthetic chews are more consistent in quality and less likely to cause digestive problems.

Final Verdict

Puppy teething chews provide essential relief during the challenging teething phase from 8 weeks to 8 months. The KONG Puppy Classic delivers outstanding versatility with interactive features, while the Benebone Wishbone offers unmatched durability for aggressive chewers. The Himalayan Yak Chews provide exceptional long-term value despite their premium positioning.

Choose based on your puppy's chewing style, your budget, and supervision capabilities - each option addresses the critical need for safe, effective teething relief during this important developmental stage.

---

Related: Check out our guides on best dog beds for large breeds, best automatic pet feeders, and best dog toys.